Internal Org Mail Routing   

Hi all,

I have 2 messaging org, 1 is based on exchange 2007 [target] and another on 
2003 [source].  Both orgs have the same Primary SMTP address e.g. abc.org.  I 
have added additional SMTP addresses of target.org in ex2007 and source.org 
in ex 2003 org.

Now, I can send email from source to target using target user's secondary 
address e.g. USER 1@target.org and email routes just fine.  The problem 
occurs in repliability, if I add the option of 'read receipt' or 'delivery 
receipt', the source user never gets any of the receipts.  Also, when the 
target user replies to the email that was send by source on 'target.org' 
address, the source user's address shows as User b@abc.org.  But the when the 
target user replies to the email from source, it does not route it back to 
source.   I guess since the address shows up as abc.org, exchange tries to 
look up the 'user b@abc.org' in target exch 2007 org.  Shouldn't exchange in 
target org route the mail based on secondary smtp of source.org since primary 
SMTP is similar in both orgs?

Any suggestions??

TIA
Jason

date: Thu, 8 May 2008 18:58:01 -0700   author:   JX

Re: Internal Org Mail Routing   

Hi Jason, it sounds like both Exchange orgs are authoritative for the 
namespace abc.org, so if they don't find the recipient in their local GAL 
they don't look elsewhere.  A good article on sharing address spaces is:

http://support.microsoft.com/kb/321721/en-us

That article is for Exchange 2003, so it will only address half of your 
problem.  Based on the names below, are you doing a migration and trying to 
establish coexistence mailflow while the migration is taking place?

-- 
Chad Mosman
M3 Postmasters
m3postmasters@nospam.m3tg.com
www.m3postmasters.com
"JX"  wrote in message 
news:ED1416DD-0CB6-42E0-87D7-1E61F7DCC742@microsoft.com...
> Hi all,
>
> I have 2 messaging org, 1 is based on exchange 2007 [target] and another 
> on
> 2003 [source].  Both orgs have the same Primary SMTP address e.g. abc.org. 
> I
> have added additional SMTP addresses of target.org in ex2007 and 
> source.org
> in ex 2003 org.
>
> Now, I can send email from source to target using target user's secondary
> address e.g. USER 1@target.org and email routes just fine.  The problem
> occurs in repliability, if I add the option of 'read receipt' or 'delivery
> receipt', the source user never gets any of the receipts.  Also, when the
> target user replies to the email that was send by source on 'target.org'
> address, the source user's address shows as User b@abc.org.  But the when 
> the
> target user replies to the email from source, it does not route it back to
> source.   I guess since the address shows up as abc.org, exchange tries to
> look up the 'user b@abc.org' in target exch 2007 org.  Shouldn't exchange 
> in
> target org route the mail based on secondary smtp of source.org since 
> primary
> SMTP is similar in both orgs?
>
> Any suggestions??
>
> TIA
> Jason

date: Fri, 9 May 2008 08:12:30 -0400   author:   Chad Mosman [M3 Postmasters]

Re: Internal Org Mail Routing   

Chad,

Thanks for your response.
Yes, I am migrating [or setting a stage for migration] from 2 legacy e2k3 
orgs to e2k7 org.  All three orgs will be authoritative for 'abc.org' 
namespace for internal mail routing/forwarding purposes.  The legacy exch org 
[one of them] will be getting all the inbound internet mail during 
coexistence period.  After migration, i will flip external internet mail 
routing [inbound/outbound] to e2k7.  

You are right, that since both the orgs [e2k3 & 7] are auth for smtp 
namespace 'abc.org', they look in their own org for reply address and thats 
it.  The solution may be to add Contact objects from e2k3 to e2k7 and vice 
versa for the coexistence period.  Or another solution may be to populate the 
'targetAddress' attribute on the mailboxes.  Your thoughts....

TIA

"Chad Mosman [M3 Postmasters]" wrote:

> Hi Jason, it sounds like both Exchange orgs are authoritative for the 
> namespace abc.org, so if they don't find the recipient in their local GAL 
> they don't look elsewhere.  A good article on sharing address spaces is:
> 
> http://support.microsoft.com/kb/321721/en-us
> 
> That article is for Exchange 2003, so it will only address half of your 
> problem.  Based on the names below, are you doing a migration and trying to 
> establish coexistence mailflow while the migration is taking place?
> 
> -- 
> Chad Mosman
> M3 Postmasters
> m3postmasters@nospam.m3tg.com
> www.m3postmasters.com
> "JX"  wrote in message 
> news:ED1416DD-0CB6-42E0-87D7-1E61F7DCC742@microsoft.com...
> > Hi all,
> >
> > I have 2 messaging org, 1 is based on exchange 2007 [target] and another 
> > on
> > 2003 [source].  Both orgs have the same Primary SMTP address e.g. abc.org. 
> > I
> > have added additional SMTP addresses of target.org in ex2007 and 
> > source.org
> > in ex 2003 org.
> >
> > Now, I can send email from source to target using target user's secondary
> > address e.g. USER 1@target.org and email routes just fine.  The problem
> > occurs in repliability, if I add the option of 'read receipt' or 'delivery
> > receipt', the source user never gets any of the receipts.  Also, when the
> > target user replies to the email that was send by source on 'target.org'
> > address, the source user's address shows as User b@abc.org.  But the when 
> > the
> > target user replies to the email from source, it does not route it back to
> > source.   I guess since the address shows up as abc.org, exchange tries to
> > look up the 'user b@abc.org' in target exch 2007 org.  Shouldn't exchange 
> > in
> > target org route the mail based on secondary smtp of source.org since 
> > primary
> > SMTP is similar in both orgs?
> >
> > Any suggestions??
> >
> > TIA
> > Jason 
>

date: Fri, 9 May 2008 08:19:07 -0700   author:   JX