|
|
|
date: Fri, 20 Jan 2006 07:36:05 -0800,
group: microsoft.public.sqlserver.mseq
back
Re: Promt user for criteria ?
On Fri, 20 Jan 2006 07:36:05 -0800, Xavier wrote:
>I know it can be done with a SP but is there a way to prompt a user for
>specific criteria like date range (between ? and ?) in a view.
>I have a query in a view but I need to prompt the user for a date range, my
>front end is access 2002 I can do it as a passthrough but it takes to long to
>run and while testing I found that as a view it runs in half the time.
Hi Xavier,
SQL Server can't ever prompt the user. Not in a view, and not in a
stored procedure either.
If you refer to prompting for arguments in the front end, then passing
them as parameters to the back end: that is possible in stored procs,
but not in a view. But you can use variables in a SELECT statement that
queries a view.
However, I am intrigued by your statement that you found a view to be
faster than a stored procedure. While I don't doubt your observations,
I'm pretty sure that there's no such blanket statement about performance
of views vs stored procedures. I suspect that is has something to do
with the specific details of your tables, your stored procedure and your
view.
To investigate this further, you'll have to give more details: how do
your tables look (CREATE TABLE statements), how are the view and the
stored procedure defined (CREATE VIEW / CREATE PROC), what does your
data typically look like (INSERT statements for a small sample of your
data) and how do you call the view and the stored proc?
Chcek out www.aspfaq.com/5006 for some tips on how to assemble this
information.
--
Hugo Kornelis, SQL Server MVP
date: Sat, 21 Jan 2006 23:16:33 +0100
author: Hugo Kornelis
Re: Promt user for criteria ?
Hugo
You are correct I mistakenly said faster than a SP but I should has said
faster that a passthrough query from my front end which is access.
I could not run my report from access unless I add the view to my access
front ent as a linked table, is there any other way ? for an access report to
run a sql view and pass a parameter, like a date range to extrack particular
data example ()now
minus 48hrs everytime the user runs it.
Thanks
Xavier
"Hugo Kornelis" wrote:
> On Fri, 20 Jan 2006 07:36:05 -0800, Xavier wrote:
>
> >I know it can be done with a SP but is there a way to prompt a user for
> >specific criteria like date range (between ? and ?) in a view.
> >I have a query in a view but I need to prompt the user for a date range, my
> >front end is access 2002 I can do it as a passthrough but it takes to long to
> >run and while testing I found that as a view it runs in half the time.
>
> Hi Xavier,
>
> SQL Server can't ever prompt the user. Not in a view, and not in a
> stored procedure either.
>
> If you refer to prompting for arguments in the front end, then passing
> them as parameters to the back end: that is possible in stored procs,
> but not in a view. But you can use variables in a SELECT statement that
> queries a view.
>
> However, I am intrigued by your statement that you found a view to be
> faster than a stored procedure. While I don't doubt your observations,
> I'm pretty sure that there's no such blanket statement about performance
> of views vs stored procedures. I suspect that is has something to do
> with the specific details of your tables, your stored procedure and your
> view.
>
> To investigate this further, you'll have to give more details: how do
> your tables look (CREATE TABLE statements), how are the view and the
> stored procedure defined (CREATE VIEW / CREATE PROC), what does your
> data typically look like (INSERT statements for a small sample of your
> data) and how do you call the view and the stored proc?
>
> Chcek out www.aspfaq.com/5006 for some tips on how to assemble this
> information.
>
> --
> Hugo Kornelis, SQL Server MVP
>
date: Mon, 23 Jan 2006 06:36:03 -0800
author: Xavier
Re: Promt user for criteria ?
On Mon, 23 Jan 2006 06:36:03 -0800, Xavier wrote:
>Hugo
>
>You are correct I mistakenly said faster than a SP but I should has said
>faster that a passthrough query from my front end which is access.
>
>I could not run my report from access unless I add the view to my access
>front ent as a linked table, is there any other way ? for an access report to
>run a sql view and pass a parameter, like a date range to extrack particular
>data example ()now
>minus 48hrs everytime the user runs it.
Hi Xavier,
When using Access, you want to make sure that network traffic is kept at
a minimum. Stored procedures and pass-through queries meet this
requirement without any doubt. I'm less sure about queries on linked
tables.
I have read reports claiming that Access will fetch a complete linked
table over the network to execute the query client-side. I have also
read reports claiming that the former reports are rubbish. My personal
experience with Access is too limited to be able to tell which reports
are true and which aren't. If you want to find out, then run a profiler
trace while running Access and check what Access really sends to the
server.
I would personally use a stored procedure, but that's probably because
I'm more at ease on SQL Server - I know how to squeeze every drop of
performance out of the SP code; I'm not nearrly as proficient in
optimizing Jet SQL.
If your tests indicate that an Access query on an Access linked table
(to a SQL Server table or view) is faster than calling a stored
procedure, then by all means go for it.
--
Hugo Kornelis, SQL Server MVP
date: Mon, 23 Jan 2006 23:14:24 +0100
author: Hugo Kornelis
Re: Promt user for criteria ?
Hugo
Thank you, based on your experience with SQL can you recommend
and good books on SP and queries within sql.
We are planning on moving from access as a front end reporting tool and
replacing it with Crystal Reports, any thoughts on this you might want to
share?
We have a web based application where our users need to print certain forms
with the data that is on their screen plus a little more not seen at the
moment
that we have determined this information will print on every form allways.
The provider of our web based application which uses a propriatary tool kit
together with FrontPage to compile the forms will only support Access or
Crystal Reports.
Thanks
Xavier
"Hugo Kornelis" wrote:
> On Mon, 23 Jan 2006 06:36:03 -0800, Xavier wrote:
>
> >Hugo
> >
> >You are correct I mistakenly said faster than a SP but I should has said
> >faster that a passthrough query from my front end which is access.
> >
> >I could not run my report from access unless I add the view to my access
> >front ent as a linked table, is there any other way ? for an access report to
> >run a sql view and pass a parameter, like a date range to extrack particular
> >data example ()now
> >minus 48hrs everytime the user runs it.
>
> Hi Xavier,
>
> When using Access, you want to make sure that network traffic is kept at
> a minimum. Stored procedures and pass-through queries meet this
> requirement without any doubt. I'm less sure about queries on linked
> tables.
>
> I have read reports claiming that Access will fetch a complete linked
> table over the network to execute the query client-side. I have also
> read reports claiming that the former reports are rubbish. My personal
> experience with Access is too limited to be able to tell which reports
> are true and which aren't. If you want to find out, then run a profiler
> trace while running Access and check what Access really sends to the
> server.
>
> I would personally use a stored procedure, but that's probably because
> I'm more at ease on SQL Server - I know how to squeeze every drop of
> performance out of the SP code; I'm not nearrly as proficient in
> optimizing Jet SQL.
>
> If your tests indicate that an Access query on an Access linked table
> (to a SQL Server table or view) is faster than calling a stored
> procedure, then by all means go for it.
>
> --
> Hugo Kornelis, SQL Server MVP
>
date: Thu, 26 Jan 2006 18:31:01 -0800
author: Xavier
|
|
